Critical Review of Bouchaib (2022): The Sino-African Higher Education Exchange

-

Introduction

The article The Sino-African Higher Education Exchange: Toward Building a Literature by Bouchaib (2022) provides a thematic literature review on Sino-African education cooperation and exchange from 2005 to 2022. The author examines key themes in existing research, such as the historical development of Sino-African education relations, the frameworks of cooperation, vocational training and knowledge transfer, and the soft power implications of educational exchange. Bouchaib argues that while the field has gained significant academic attention, much of the research remains polemical, often divided between Western critiques and Chinese perspectives. The study calls for more empirical research beyond political debates to evaluate the actual impact of China’s educational engagement in Africa.

A screenshot of the journal article by Bouchaib.

The article contributes to the growing body of knowledge on China’s educational diplomacy in Africa by comparing English and Chinese-language literature. However, while it effectively organizes the existing scholarship into thematic categories, it has limitations in methodological clarity, theoretical engagement, and regional comparisons, which could have strengthened the overall analysis.

Summary of Key Points

Bouchaib identifies six major themes in the literature on Sino-African higher education exchanges. First, the article traces the historical evolution of China-Africa education cooperation from the 1950s to the present, highlighting key policy shifts from ideological aid to economic and strategic collaboration under the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI). The study also explores the nature of Sino-African education engagement, debating whether it constitutes “cooperation” or “aid”. While Chinese scholars emphasize mutual development and partnership, Western researchers often characterize China’s educational initiatives as a form of strategic aid aimed at expanding influence in Africa.

Another significant theme is the role of vocational training and knowledge transfer in China-Africa cooperation. Bouchaib discusses how China has prioritized technical education and skill-building programs to align with its economic investments in Africa. The study also examines the experiences of African students in China, including challenges related to cultural adaptation, discrimination, and employment opportunities after graduation.

Finally, the article addresses China’s use of education as a soft power strategy, arguing that while China aims to cultivate pro-China sentiment among African students, language barriers, cultural misalignment, and negative student experiences sometimes hinder these efforts. The author calls for more empirical studies to assess the long-term impact of China’s higher education policies in Africa.

Critical Analysis

Bouchaib’s article provides a valuable contribution by synthesizing key debates and structuring the literature on Sino-African education cooperation. The comprehensive thematic approach allows readers to understand how different research perspectives shape the discourse on China’s role in African higher education. The inclusion of both English and Chinese-language sources adds depth to the analysis, making it more representative of diverse viewpoints.

However, the article has several weaknesses. One of the main limitations is its lack of a strong theoretical foundation. While Bouchaib references the soft power concept, there is little engagement with key scholars such as Joseph Nye (1990, 2004) or theories of public diplomacy and higher education internationalization. A deeper theoretical discussion could have strengthened the study’s analytical depth.

Another issue is methodological transparency. The article claims to have conducted a literature review using a qualitative thematic approach, but it does not clearly explain how sources were selected, categorized, or analyzed beyond citation metrics. A more detailed explanation of the coding process and data selection criteria would have enhanced the study’s credibility and replicability.

Additionally, the article lacks comparative perspectives beyond Africa. While the study is Africa-focused, including comparisons with China’s higher education exchanges in Southeast Asia or Latin America could have provided a broader context for evaluating the uniqueness of China-Africa educational ties.

Moreover, while the article discusses challenges African students face in China, it underexplores how these experiences influence China’s reputation in Africa or impact students’ career trajectories upon returning home. Addressing these aspects through empirical research, interviews, or surveys could have provided a more comprehensive assessment of the long-term effects of educational exchanges.

Evaluation and Conclusion

Bouchaib (2022) presents an important contribution to the field of Sino-African education cooperation by organizing key research themes and identifying gaps in the literature. The article successfully highlights how education serves as a bridge for China’s diplomatic, economic, and cultural engagement with Africa. However, the lack of theoretical depth, methodological clarity, and comparative analysis weakens its overall impact.

Despite these shortcomings, the study is valuable for scholars and policymakers seeking to understand China’s growing influence in African higher education. Future research could build upon Bouchaib’s review by incorporating empirical studies, comparative case studies, and stronger theoretical frameworks to evaluate the real impact of China’s educational initiatives on African development and diplomacy.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

FPA: Organizational Process Model

-
This model centers on the fact that different bureaucracies have different standard operating procedures. These procedures are made in order to allow day to day operations to be carried out. Thus, a foreign policy decision is made based on these standard operating procedures. It is hard for a bureaucracy to make a decision or let alone function out of character or contrary to their standard operating procedure. The reading Chapter 4: Foreign policy shares a straight forward explanation of the OPM: "An alternative to the rational model of decision making is the organizational process model. In this model, foreign policy decision makers generally skip the labor-intensive process of identifying goals and alternative actions, relying instead for most decisions on standardized responses or standard operating procedures. For example, the U.S. State Department everyday receives more than a thousand reports or inquiries from its embassies around the world and sends out more than a ...
Read more

Commercial liberalism and the six norms

-
Image
Liberal internationalism is defined by Griffiths, O'Callaghan and Roach (2008, p.190) as a project to transform international relations so that they conform to models of peace, freedom, and prosperity allegedly enjoyed within constitutional liberal democracies. The same scholars go further by dividing liberalism into three distinct groups. They say these are the three ways to implement the project. The way they present liberal internationalism as a project makes their work interesting. Three distinct groups Firstly, commercial liberalism is about free trade between states. States bilaterally or multilaterally via a platform like APEC pursue the goal of trade liberalization. Griffiths, O'Callagahan and Roach (ibid.) argued that economic interdependence would decrease the likelihood of going to war. Republican liberalism is about democratic peace. The scholars argued that the spread of democracy among states so that governments will be accountable to their citizens makes it di...
Read more

Allison's rational actor model

-
There are 3 common models of foreign policy decision making according to Graham Allison: rational actor model organizational process mode government politics model.  We will discuss the 3 models and compare them with the 3 levels of analysis. However, I challenge you to use your own initiative to learn about the other models of decision making. This will help you as future decision makers or analysts to understand how decisions are made and the processes. When one wakes up from bed he or she decides whether or not to brush their teeth, comb their hair and have a shower. These decisions are paramount, they affect and influence how the individual interacts in a social setting. This highlights the fact that as human beings we make decisions every day. Decision making is defined as the thought process of selecting a logical choice from the available options. In the case of the ‘Kibung peles boy’ analogy; the male student had a choice of approaching the girl to ask he...
Read more